Soft Plastic Colours: What Works in Clear vs Dirty Water (Simple System)

by

Soft plastic colors are a rabbit hole. You can waste years collecting “magic colors” and still fish poorly.

Here’s the truth: color matters less than weight, zone and pause — but it still matters enough that having a simple system helps. This guide is that system.

The 3-bucket color system

You only need three categories of color:

  1. Natural / translucent (clear water default)
  2. Dark / silhouette (dirty water + low light)
  3. Bright / change-up (pattern break when you need a shock)

If you keep one color in each bucket, you’ll cover most sessions without decision fatigue.

What color soft plastic is best for clear water?

In clear water, natural or translucent soft plastic colors usually work best because fish can see detail and can be wary. Choose baitfish or prawn-like tones that look believable. If you’re unsure, start natural and focus on good jighead weight and pauses—presentation matters more than chasing “secret” colors.

What color soft plastic is best for dirty water?

In dirty water or low light, darker colors often work well because they create a stronger silhouette and contrast. Fish can track contrast more easily than fine detail when visibility is poor. Start with a dark profile, slow down your retrieve, and keep contact so you can detect subtle bites.

How sunlight and depth change color

Even in clear water, depth reduces color accuracy and increases the importance of contrast.

Practical takeaway:

  • shallow + bright sun → natural/translucent often shines
  • deeper or low light → contrast starts to matter more

When to use bright “change-up” colors

Bright colors aren’t “wrong”. They’re just often better as a pattern break.

Use bright when:

  • fish are following but not eating
  • you’ve tried natural + dark with no response
  • the water is weird (stained, tannin, churned)

The mistake is starting bright every session and never learning what fish actually wanted.

The “2 colors only” starter rule

If you’re building confidence, use:

  • 1 natural (default)
  • 1 dark (backup)

Fish those until you can catch consistently, then add bright as your change-up.

Common color mistakes

Mistake 1: changing color every 10 casts

If you change constantly, you never learn.

Change weight or zone first. Color comes after that.

Mistake 2: ignoring contrast

Sometimes it’s not about “green vs brown” — it’s about can the fish see it.

Mistake 3: forgetting the lure profile

Profile and sink rate often outfish color changes.

Helpful external resources

Leave a Comment